14 Comments

Another great piece! But I also think that anytime we're talking about social/emotional labor and kinkeeping, we can also tell women it's OK to dial it down, to stop setting the bar so high to create "holiday magic."

That feminism can and should include being more minimal about capitalistic expectations (I will never, ever buy an elf on the shelf), holiday "decorating," on and on. If you love that sort of thing, go for it, but your family will not suffer if you don't buy fancy napkins or send out Xmas cards or order delivery for the big meal or simply let the Amazon packing count as gift wrap.

It's profitable to burden women with the guilt of creating "holiday magic" but we can redefine and set limits on that. So important for kids to see that happening, too.

(As comic Trey Kennedy says "do less/god bless)

Expand full comment

Yes ALL of this. Well said! I considered writing a post on this too but I've seen a few already. And for the record, if I celebrated Christmas I wouldn't buy an elf on the shelf either. It's a bit creepy! 😂

Expand full comment

lol our kids have begged and begged for one 😂 we still don’t have it

Expand full comment

My mother taught me to lavish my Christmas energy where I want to and set boundaries around the rest. So I love the gift-giving, but I forego ribbons on my packages (who has time?) and serve Eggo waffles and thawed strawberries from the freezer on Christmas, as she did for us as kids. “Christmas is a holiday for me, too,” she said every year, while we padded to the kitchen in our slippers to toast our prize waffles when we felt like it.

Expand full comment

Your mom sounds very wise! Glad you've carried on the practice of self-preservation which sounds like it's led to lovely traditions.

Expand full comment

This is Lizzie’s husband. I don’t consider myself a hardcore feminist but I do like pointing out unfair incongruities in expectations between men and women. This is such a well written title that I already agreed before even reading it. I, lightly surprised at myself, totally agree that society would be better if the expectation was equally shared and glorified between men and women.

Well written. Well done.

Expand full comment

Aw thanks Lizzie’s husband! Glad it resonated and thanks for letting me know.

Expand full comment

Merry Christmas to all:)

Voting all done 😁

Expand full comment

Merry Christmas Boris! And thanks so much for voting :)

Expand full comment

In my family, only the stocking presents come from Santa. Still totally magical but I feel like it sets up a good dynamic for the kids to understand where the big stuff comes from!

Expand full comment

That is brilliant!

Expand full comment

Voted! Good luck !

Expand full comment

Aw thanks so much Nancia!

Expand full comment

Loved this!!! Christmas has gotten easier as my kids have gotten older, but this totally brought me back to those years where “making the magic” felt like it was 100% my responsibility.

Expand full comment